The Proud and Profane

1956

1h 51m

IMDb RATING

6.2/10

YOUR RATING

Rate

POPULARITY

Play trailer

0 Videos

14 Images

Drama

Romance

In this romantic drama, beautiful Red Cross volunteer Lee Ashley arrives on the South Pacific island of New Caledonia to learn more about the circumstances surrounding the death of her husband, Howard, in the Battle of Guadalcanal. There, Ashley falls for the gruff, seductive Marine Lt. Col. Colin Buck, but struggle and tragedy follow when the widow learns about the reality of Buck's life back home.

Directors

George Seaton

Writers

Lucy Herndon Crockett(novel by)

George Seaton(screenplay by)

George Seaton(story by)

Stars

William Holden

Deborah Kerr

Thelma Ritter

See production, box office & company info

Photos14

Top cast

Lt. Col. Colin Black

Lee Ashley

Kate Connors

Eddie Wodcik

Chaplain Lt. (jg) Holmes

Louie

Eustace Press

Joan

Bob Kilpatrick

Major

Lieutenant (jg) Hutchins

Ward Wood

Sergeant Chester Peckinpaugh

Helen

Beth

Pat

Evvie

Sissie

Soldier

Directors

George Seaton

Writers

Lucy Herndon Crockett(novel by)

George Seaton(screenplay by)

George Seaton(story by)

All cast & crew

Production, box office & more at IMDbPro

User reviews1

Review

Featured review

6/10

"Lee" (Deborah Kerr) travels to the French colony of New Caledonia to do what she can for the war effort and after a brief conversation with her boss "Kate" (Thelma Ritter) we discover that she's gone all that way because her husband was killed at Guadalcanal. She's advised to focus on her nursing responsibilities and not to risk getting involved with any of the soldiers, and that goes fine until she butts heads with "Col. Black" (William Holden). He knew her late husband, or so he tells her, and as she clamours for more information about when, where and how he died the inevitable happens. Of course, we all know that something built on a pack lies isn't going to prove very robust, and as the deceit - and there's plenty of that on both sides as the story advances - is exposed, their relationship faces turmoil and tragedy. It's only when she finally reaches her husband's grave that things are put into true perspective. Might it all be too late by then? Thelma Ritter is always a reliable character actress but she has too little to get her teeth into here to make enough difference to whet is otherwise a rather pedestrian melodrama that neither Kerr nor Holden seem to be able to enliven. Even at their most torrid, their romance comes across as dry as a bone, indeed there's not much likeable about their characters and so I didn't really care what happened to either of them as this frankly quite thin story is stretched out for at least twenty minutes too long and seems contrived to introduce unwelcome baggage at just about every turn. To be fair, it's quite tightly cast and the story remains focussed on the two of them well enough, but I found the whole thing just too soapy and disinteresting.

Geronimo196705 Jan, 2025